Index: src/station_gui.cpp
===================================================================
--- src/station_gui.cpp	(revision 8591)
+++ src/station_gui.cpp	(working copy)
@@ -145,8 +145,9 @@
 	int j;
 
 	for (j = 0; j < NUM_CARGO; j++) {
-		if (st1->goods[j].waiting_acceptance & 0xfff) maxr1 = max(maxr1, st1->goods[j].rating);
-		if (st2->goods[j].waiting_acceptance & 0xfff) maxr2 = max(maxr2, st2->goods[j].rating);
+		//using same criteria used to display ratings in DrawStationViewWindow
+		if (st1->goods[j].enroute_from != INVALID_STATION) maxr1 = max(maxr1, st1->goods[j].rating);
+		if (st2->goods[j].enroute_from != INVALID_STATION) maxr2 = max(maxr2, st2->goods[j].rating);
 	}
 
 	return (_internal_sort_order & 1) ? maxr2 - maxr1 : maxr1 - maxr2;